Reader Response Blog #2
The passage that i read that had the most impact on me was, “We waited as Doyle walked a little ahead of his position, hands on his hips, and looked out to the field ahead of us. Behind us, I heard choppers. I turned and saw them headed for us. They went by us out to the target zone. “Hey Scotty, did we. . .?” “Yep, we just shot the shit out of the first platoon.”
I can only wonder what was flowing through Perry’s mind when he realized that they’d just wounded, and killed their comrades. I understand that soldiers would be paranoid, and its easy to see how they could mistake comrades with allies in the forest of Vietnam. In an earlier passage, they called in Willy Peter, which was a type of artillery used to level whole areas of forested land. I can’t imagine the trauma that would occur from knowing that you killed someone on your side, even if it was just an accident. If I were Perry, I’d probably try to quit the war, and go back home. I’d try to forget that it ever happened, or try to get rid of any guilty from it. This passage gave a new insight to war that I hadn’t considered before reading it.
03/25/2010 at 12:41 PM
I agree that this must have been difficult for Perry to comprehend. Killing ones own men raises the curtain on their mind and brings them back to reality. Your quote was excellent, and your interpretation of it wasn’t flawed all that much. I would also go back home if it were truly possible to go home early without getting injured.
03/25/2010 at 12:47 PM
As we talked about 5 minutes ago, the army is corrupted and the probablity of our winning the war w/o withdrawing is debatable.
03/25/2010 at 12:54 PM
I agree. I think it would be incredibly painful to realize that you have killed people who are close to you…even people who aren’t close to you. I suspect this incident will cause great pain, guilt, shame, and post traumatic stress for Perry. I know I would never be able to handle anything like that, so for Perry to truly experience it…I think that would have been the hardest thing in his life to endure.